Woven Music: an Invitation

In 1623, a Welsh guy sat down and wrote some binary code:

He wasn’t a software developer, four centuries ahead of his time; he was a harp player, very much of his time: these codes portray a beautifully medieval sensibility. Two harmonies alternate back and forth in intricate patterns, like woven tartan cloth or a Celtic knot.

This post explores these woven patterns, which anyone can use to make music. The patterns are intricate but simple. You can fit any sound or musical idea into each ‘1’ and each ‘0’. Any chord, progression, rhythmic pattern, or tune, whether just a couple of notes or longer phrases, will work. Then lay it out according to the pattern, tweak it to make sure it’s not too mechanical, and sit back to enjoy luscious expanses of interesting, ever-changing music.

This can be a great tool for songwriters and lyricists looking for alternatives to standard formats (verse-chorus, verse-chorus…). Take a couple of phrases and alternate them according to one of these patterns, and you’ll get some lovely fresh moments of contrast in your songs. The patterns are a fun way to structure lyrics too. They can serve as rhyme schemes, each 1 or 0 as a rhyming line ending, perhaps evolving to new rhymes as the song progresses. And the same goes for alliteration.

Let’s dig in deeper to see how these patterns work.

Binary Code: Symmetry & Inversion
in Medieval Welsh Harp Music

Welsh harpist Robert ap Huw’s 1623 manuscript (see the whole thing here) laid out a system of music and memory called the

24 measures of cerdd dant [string music]

The ‘binary code’ portrays two chords or tonalities:

1 = ‘string of concord’
0 = ‘string of inflection’

For example, the Welsh measure ‘bryt odidog’

Each four is the inversion of the other:

0010 * 0010
1101 * 1101

I highly recommend listening to Bill Taylor’s re-creation of tunes from the Robert ap Huw manuscript.

These patterns exist throughout Celtic music and beyond.

In this Irish tune, listen for the pattern of alternating tonalities:

11 10 (repeated)
00 01 (repeated)

The second inverts the first.

Limited Material, Big Possibilities

These musicians loved to work with strict limits. A ten-minute tune with only four notes? No problem! Just make two contrasting musical ideas, then build them into a pattern of 1s and 0s, and you’ll have music of endless variety and interest.

Fractal Music: Broad Cloth from Little Stitches

The patterns we’ve looked at so far are short. But like fractals, these small elements can combine into broad expanses of music. Here are the two parts of the Welsh measure ‘bryt odidog’ again:

0010 * 1101

The first part is mostly 0s, and the second is mostly 1s. So let’s call the first a “big 0” and the second a “big 1”:

0010 = ‘big 0′
1101 = ‘big 1‘

Now let’s re-create the original pattern, but using our ‘big 0’ and ‘big 1’. The small ‘local’ pattern continues, but altered: it is now guided by the bigger pattern.

To demonstrate the effects of this pattern, with limited musical material, I made up a fake medieval Welsh harp song (scroll down to listen) in the style of the tunes in the 1623 Robert ap Huw manuscript, as played by Bill Taylor.

My song uses only four notes: D, E, A, B, plus one special note, F-sharp, saved up for a key moment and used sparingly.

The large 1s and 0s show the overall Welsh measure ‘bryt odidog’.
The small 1s and 0s show the pattern within each bar (heard in lower part). So the same pattern applies at two levels: fractal music! Listen below.

The phrases of my melody are not that interesting on their own, and the accompaniment is simple and repetitive. But you may find that the music sounds like it’s continually evolving and changing. There are moments when you expect one thing, and something else happens. The pattern of 1s and 0s won’t guarantee the right balance of surprise and satisfaction — that’s always going to happen in the the artistry of composing — but it’s a wonderful and fun compositional tool you can add to your kit.

For the full story on 1s and 0s, check out Barnaby Brown’s article here.

Woven Patterns in Pibroch,
the ‘Big Music’ of the Highland Bagpipe

Weaving small bits into larger patterns, using limited pitches, is the essence of Pibroch: the Baroque-era ‘classical music of the Highland Bagpipe’ of the Gaelic people of Scotland. (Gaelic spelling is piobaireachd).

16th – 18th centuries:
Gaelic-speaking, ceremonial music for war, sailing, mourning, saluting, etc.

19th – 21st centuries:
Anglicized, rarely heard, played mostly in stuffy piping competitions.

Pibroch uses woven patterns of consonance and dissonance against the drone.

Let’s go back to the Welsh Harp Measure ‘bryt odidog’:

0010 1101

It’s the same as the ‘Woven’ pattern in Pibroch, except with the 1s and 0s switched:

These are the first four of Barnaby Brown’s analysis of nine types of pibroch design.

What do ‘1’ and ‘0’ mean in pibroch?

Each digit 1 or 0 is one phrase or group of phrases in the tune; the ‘one-ness’ or ‘zero-ness’ of a phrase comes from whether the main melody notes in that phrase are consonant or dissonant with the bagpipe drone.

Bagpipe Drone note: A (mixolydian scale on A, two sharps, though it may sound at closer to a B-flat)
Consonant notes: A, C#, E
Dissonant notes: G, B, D

Canntaireachd (chanting)

Pibroch is taught by a sung ‘solfege’ system.

Each pitch, and each grace-note ornament, has its own syllable.

In this video, A stands for 1 and B stands for 0.

Canntaireachd sung by Barnaby Brown.

The dissonance or consonance of a phrase is often defined by its last note.

A Pibroch Tune

Here are the opening notes of one of the greatest pibrochs, Lament for the Viscount of Dundee:

The drone is A.
Red = dissonant phrases
Blue = consonant phrases

This video shows the uninspiring atmosphere of many piobaireachd competitions.

The tune itself, before the variations start, is 2.5 minutes long.
The full, detailed structure of the tune looks like this.

0011 0100

0:39 in the video:
0011 0100

1:18 in the video:
1100 0001

1:54 in the video:
0100 1011

Let’s zoom out on that detailed, phrase-to-phrase pattern to see the birds-eye view, the overall guiding pattern. We can do this the same way we did above: take each pair of phrases and summarize it as one ‘big 0’ or one ‘big 1’:

if:
00 and 01 = big 0

and
11 and 10 = big 1

…then we can capture the whole pattern more succinctly:

0100 0100 1000 0011

Remember the map of pibroch patterns earlier?

This tune is the ‘Lyrical well-woven’ pattern, with the digits inverted (every 1 becomes a 0 and vice versa) and a slight variation in the fifth eighth of the tune:

Again, these are the first four of Barnaby Brown’s analysis of nine types of pibroch design.

In many pibroch tunes, something different happens in the fifth eighth of the tune — a new phrase or turn to freshen the ear. Often, a specific pitch is ‘saved up’ for a special moment, occurring only once, as with the poignant F# toward the end of Lament for the Viscount of Dundee.

That same Pibroch Tune, Stolen and Redone

For my composition Hudson Running, commissioned by Vassar College in 2011, I stole that pibroch tune as a starting point, using the same pattern of 1 and 0 sonorities, but inverted.

For each phrase defined/dominated by ‘1‘ pitches A, C# and E (consonant with the drone), I switched them for ‘0‘ pitches G, B, and D (dissonant with the drone). For each ‘0‘ phrase I likewise inverted the pitches: